Trade on Sports’ “Pinny Bot” – Final Review
We have come to the end of our 18 month trial of football betting Trade On Sports’ Pinny Bot and here are the final results:-
| Profit/Loss: | +6 points |
| Strike Rate: | 70% |
| Bank Growth: | 6% |
| ROI: | 0.5% |
| Average number of bets: | 15 bets per week |
| Cost: | £39.95 every 4 weeks |
| VERDICT: | NEUTRAL |
| Rating: |
You can view full results here.
Trade On Sports’ Pinny Bot – Full Review
The Pinny Bot is a football betting system from Trade On Sports that attempts to identify value by comparing prices on the Betfair exchange with those offered by Pinnacle, one of the best-known sharp bookmakers.
We have reviewed Trade On Sports previously here at Honest Betting Reviews, with their HT Overs Bot producing some excellent profits during our earlier trial.
So when we came across Pinny Bot, we were interested to see whether it could deliver similarly impressive results.
The theory behind the system is fairly straightforward.
Pinnacle is regarded as one of the sharper bookmakers in the industry, partly because it accepts substantial bets from professional punters and tends to operate with relatively competitive margins.
As a result, its prices are often considered a useful indication of the true probabilities of sporting events.
Pinny Bot looks for occasions when the odds available on Betfair are higher than those offered by Pinnacle, suggesting there may be some value in the Betfair market.
It also examines discrepancies in the amounts matched on Betfair compared with what might be expected from the available odds.
When a suitable opportunity is identified, an alert is sent through Telegram.
The system focuses primarily on the major European football leagues, where liquidity is generally good and substantial amounts of money are matched.
An important point is that you do not need an account with Pinnacle to use Pinny Bot. All the bets can be placed on Betfair or another exchange.
How Does Pinny Bot Work?
There are several ways to follow the selections, but the principal strategy we tested was laying the opponent of the team highlighted by the bot.
For example, suppose Liverpool are playing Arsenal and Pinny Bot identifies Liverpool as offering value.
Rather than backing Liverpool, you would lay Arsenal on Betfair.
That means your bet would win if Liverpool won or the match finished in a draw.
The alternative strategy we tracked was simply backing the draw in matches identified by the bot.
Trade On Sports also suggests other approaches, including splitting stakes between laying the opposing team and backing the draw, or using correct-score markets.
The idea is that by identifying teams whose prices appear too generous on Betfair, the system might also uncover opportunities in related markets.
It’s an interesting concept, although whether a price discrepancy necessarily translates into an advantage in every associated market is another question.
That is why we wanted to monitor the results ourselves rather than relying purely on the historical figures advertised by the service.
Results Analysis
Looking at the final results, Pinny Bot managed to finish our trial in profit using both of the approaches we monitored.
The main strategy of laying the opposing team returned 6 points profit, while backing the draw produced 10 points profit.
So backing the draw finished 4 points ahead.
At first glance, neither result is particularly spectacular, especially considering the length of the trial.
However, there is quite a bit more to the story than those headline figures suggest.
A Promising Start
We started tracking Pinny Bot in October 2024, when the historical results being advertised by Trade On Sports looked very promising.
In particular, the strategy of laying the opposing team had reportedly made 67 points profit during 2024 before our trial began.
That was an impressive figure and suggested the system might have identified a genuine weakness in the betting markets.
Our own trial got off to a reasonable start.
By early January 2025, laying the opposing team had generated almost 15 points profit.
Backing the draw was also performing well, so at that stage things looked encouraging.
Unfortunately, that good form didn’t last.
A Difficult Period
During February 2025, the laying strategy suffered a downturn that wiped out all the early profits.
By the time of our February update, it was around 2 points down overall.
Results recovered during March and April, with the laying strategy moving back to 8 points profit at one stage.
However, it was struggling to build any real momentum.
By the end of the 2024/25 football season, the laying strategy had made just 1 point profit, while backing the draw had generated 10 points.
That was a modest return for several months of betting, particularly when subscription costs are taken into consideration.
The following season then proved even more challenging.
By September 2025, the laying strategy had fallen to 7 points down.
Things deteriorated further during the autumn, with the loss reaching 20 points by November and 21 points by December.
The worst point came in January 2026, when the laying strategy had accumulated a deficit of 28 points.
That was quite a substantial reversal from the promising results seen at the beginning of our trial.
Interestingly, backing the draw had performed considerably better over the same period.
At the end of January, that approach was still showing a profit of 7 points, putting it 35 points ahead of the laying strategy.
It was becoming clear that the two methods could produce very different results, despite being based on the same underlying selections.
A Strong Recovery Towards the End
To its credit, Pinny Bot did mount an impressive recovery during the final part of our trial.
Between our January and March 2026 updates, the laying strategy generated 32 points profit, completely wiping out the accumulated deficit.
That took the overall result back into positive territory at 4 points profit.
The improvement continued into our final update in May, with another 2 points added.
That left the laying strategy with a final profit of 6 points.
Backing the draw also remained profitable, although it suffered a small decline during the final period, finishing 10 points ahead overall.
It was certainly encouraging to see Pinny Bot recover from such a difficult spell.
However, the magnitude of the swings during the trial cannot be ignored.
A service that moves from nearly 15 points profit to 28 points down before recovering to finish 6 points ahead is clearly capable of producing considerable volatility.
And while the final result was positive, the overall profit was relatively modest considering the length of time involved.
What Do the Results Tell Us?
There are a few interesting observations we can make from our trial.
Firstly, the fact that both strategies finished in profit provides some support for the idea that the selections identified by Pinny Bot may contain value.
It is also worth remembering that the system operates in major football markets, where prices are generally regarded as reasonably efficient.
Finding an edge in these markets is not easy.
That said, a profit of 6 points from the main strategy over approximately 19 months is not particularly compelling evidence of a substantial betting advantage.
We would ideally want to see a stronger return, especially when allowing for the subscription fee and the considerable fluctuations experienced along the way.
The other interesting finding was the relative success of backing the draw.
That approach finished 4 points ahead of laying the opposing team and avoided some of the worst losses experienced by the main strategy.
However, we would be cautious about concluding that backing the draw is necessarily the better long-term option.
There is no obvious reason why a discrepancy between Betfair and Pinnacle prices should automatically mean that the draw is incorrectly priced.
It could simply be that draws happened to occur more frequently than expected among the selections during our trial.
Equally, it is possible that the bot is identifying some characteristic of particular matches that benefits this approach.
Without further evidence, it is difficult to say.
We would therefore be reluctant to recommend backing the draw exclusively simply because it produced the better result during our review.
Service Breakdown
Ease of use: The Pinny Bot is relatively straightforward to follow once you understand how the selections work.
Alerts are delivered through Telegram and bets can be placed directly on the Betfair exchange or your exchange of choice.
There is no need to sign up to Pinnacle or open accounts with numerous bookmakers, which is a definite advantage.
However, some familiarity with exchange betting is useful, particularly when it comes to laying selections and understanding betting liabilities.
The system also focuses mainly on the big European football leagues, so activity can slow considerably during the summer months.
Overall, we found it a reasonably simple service to follow without the need to spend hours monitoring matches.
Availability of prices: This is one of the stronger aspects of Pinny Bot.
As the system operates mainly in the major European football leagues, liquidity on Betfair is generally good.
That means there should usually be reasonable opportunities to get bets matched, although prices can move between the alert being issued and a bet being placed.
The fact that everything takes place on an exchange also avoids the familiar problem of bookmaker account restrictions.
Strike rate: The strike rate during our trial was 70% for laying the selections, which was pretty solid.
The results suggest bettors need to be prepared for some difficult periods rather than expecting a steady stream of profits however.
Advised Betting Bank: Given the fluctuations during our trial, we would suggest taking a fairly conservative approach to staking.
A bank of at least 100 points would be a reasonable starting consideration for bettors using a carefully controlled level-stakes approach.
However, with lay betting it is important to distinguish between the stake and the potential liability.
For example, a 1-point lay at odds of 3.00 carries a potential liability of 2 points.
That means the risk can vary considerably depending on the prices involved.
Anyone following Pinny Bot should make sure their staking plan accounts for that variation rather than treating every lay bet as carrying the same risk.
Subscription costs: Pinny Bot is included within Trade On Sports’ Football Gold subscription, rather than being sold as a standalone service.
This means subscribers also gain access to other football betting systems offered by Trade On Sports.
That could make the overall package more attractive if you intend to use several of their strategies.
However, judged purely on the performance of Pinny Bot during our trial, the financial returns were fairly limited.
At £10 per point, for example, the main laying strategy would have generated just £60 profit before subscription costs over the whole review period.
Backing the draw would have produced £100 at the same stakes.
Those figures make it difficult to justify subscribing solely for Pinny Bot on the basis of our trial results.
For existing Trade On Sports members, however, it could still be an interesting additional system to follow.
OVERALL VERDICT: NEUTRAL
Trade On Sports’ Pinny Bot is an interesting football betting system with a logical approach to identifying value in the markets.
The main strategy of laying the opposing team finished with just 6 points profit, while backing the draw returned 10 points profit.
Those are positive figures, but not particularly exciting ones considering the length of the review.
Based solely on the evidence from our trial, we don’t feel it has demonstrated a sufficiently strong or consistent betting edge to earn a passed rating.
We are therefore awarding Pinny Bot a NEUTRAL rating.
It is an interesting system with some potential, but we would want to see stronger and more consistent profits before recommending it as a standalone reason to subscribe to Trade On Sports.
————————————————————————————————————————————————————————–
Trade On Sports’ Pinny Bot – Results Update
6th May 2026
There’s been a small improvement for football betting system Trade On Sports‘ Pinny Bot lately, with a profit of 2 points made from laying the specified team since our last update.
That means it is now 6 points up for laying the specified team for our trial overall.
You can view full results here.
The results for backing the draw have suffered a slight drop however, with a loss of 7 points made since our last update, meaning they are now 10 points up for our trial overall for backing the draw.
So backing the draw is now doing 4 points better than laying the sp

