Free vs. Paid Sports Tipsters: Which Offers Better Value in 2024?

Did you know that 67% of sports bettors use tipster services to inform their wagers? It’s true!

Whether you’re a seasoned punter or just starting out, the age-old debate of free vs. paid sports tipsters is likely to cross your mind.

In this article, we’ll dive deep into the world of sports tipping, exploring the advantages and drawbacks of both free and paid services.

Buckle up, because by the end of this read, you’ll have all the insights you need to make an informed decision about which option offers the best bang for your buck (or lack thereof)!

 

Understanding the Basics of Sports Tipsters

First let’s take a look at the basics of sports tipsters, their history and the role of tipster platforms in more recent times. 

Definition of Sports Tipsters and Their Role in Betting

A sports tipster provides predictions, advice, or “tips” on sporting events, aiming to help bettors make more informed decisions.

Tipsters analyse various factors like team form, player injuries, and statistical data to forecast outcomes.

Their role is to sift through the data so you don’t have to, ideally giving you a better chance of beating the bookies.

Brief History of Sports Tipping Services

Sports tipping has been around as long as sports betting itself, with enthusiasts sharing advice informally.

There are tales of tipsters offering their services at horse racing meetings hundreds of years ago. It sounds like it was quite informal in those days, but wherever there’s been betting, there’s also been tipping. 

For much of the last century, tipping was provided mainly via newspapers and phone lines. The former included a mixture of free and paid tips whilst the latter was generally a paid-for service.

However, the advent of the internet and social media has revolutionised the tipping industry.

Tipsters once found in newspaper columns have now moved to online platforms, where their predictions reach a global audience instantly.

And there are now thousands of tipsters able to offer their services online, compared to just a select few in the pre-internet days. 

The Rise of Online Tipster Platforms

In recent years, online platforms dedicated to tipsters have surged in popularity. 

One of the main vehicles these days is tipster platforms, which allow budding tipsters to offer their services to punters through a website that handles all the admin, marketing and sign-up process for them. 

The most popular tipster platforms include sites like Betting Gods, Tipstrr and Surewin. 

Other vehicles for online tipsters to offer their services include social media accounts and dedicated websites. Overall the options for bettors have never been more varied.

These modern tipster platforms offer a mix of accessibility, community, and professional expertise, making it easier than ever for bettors to find the right tipster for their needs.

 

The Appeal of Free Sports Tipsters

The main advantages of free sports tipsters include: 

Accessibility and Low Barrier to Entry

The most obvious advantage of free tipsters is cost—or rather, the lack of it.

They’re readily available on social media, betting forums, and free platforms, making it easy for anyone to start following tips without financial commitment in terms of a subscription.

Free tipsters are particularly appealing for beginners who are still learning the ropes and want to test the waters without risking extra money on subscriptions.

Whilst some people doubt the quality of free tipsters – “they can’t be any good if they’re giving their tips away for free” – in reality there are a number of good free tipsters out there. 

Whether it’s Ben Coley in golf, Hugh Taylor in horse racing or Andy Schooler in tennis, there are a number of free tipsters who have proved their worth. 

It’s important to remember that there are other ways for tipsters to make money from their tips other than charging a subscription – advertising, or receiving a salary as part of a newspaper or large betting website for example – so we should not dismiss them just because they don’t charge for their tips. 

Variety of Free Tipster Options Available

One of the beauties of free tipsters is the sheer variety.

Whether you’re into football, tennis, or niche sports like handball, there’s a free tipster out there providing daily advice.

This variety allows bettors to explore different markets and strategies without being tied to one specific paid service.

Potential for Discovering Up-and-Coming Talent

Many free tipsters are individuals who are passionate about sports and betting, some of whom may eventually evolve into paid professionals.

By following free tipsters, you may discover hidden gems—experts on the rise who offer valuable insight without the hefty price tag (at least for now).

 

The Advantages of Paid Sports Tipsters

Some of the advantages of paid sports tipsters include: 

Professional Expertise and Dedicated Research

Paid tipsters often have a professional approach to their craft, investing significant time into research and analysis.

They may use advanced betting models, statistical tools, or knowledge of niche markets to provide specialised tips.

By paying for tips, you’re tapping into expertise that comes from a professional devoted to their craft.  

If you go through our lists of the best tipsters in each sport – compiled on the basis of hundreds of reviews we’ve conducted over the last ten years – you will see that most of the best tipsters are paid tipping services. 

• Best Football Tipsters
• Best Horse Racing Tipsters
• Best Golf Tipsters
• Best Tennis Tipsters
• Best Boxing Tipsters

The top tipsters in these lists are professionals who have honed their craft and produced substantial profit over the course of many years. 

Whilst there are some good free tipsters in those lists too, unfortunately most of them tend to suffer from problems of odds availability, which is a topic we will discuss further below.  

Odds Availability

One of the main advantages of paid versus free tips is that with a limited membership, paid tipsters often do not see their tips backed as heavily as those of free tipsters.

With 100 or 200 members for a paid tipster versus potentially thousands following a free tipster, the difference in price pressure can be quite significant.

A paid tipster can also cap membership when they feel that numbers are starting to influence prices, where as a free tipster has no such mechanism.  

Customized Advice and Personalized Service

Many paid services offer more than just general tips.

They can provide customized advice tailored to your betting style, budget, and risk tolerance.

Some even offer direct communication with the tipster, allowing for personalized guidance that doesn’t tend to happen with free services.

 

The Hidden Cost of Free Tipsters – Dropping Odds

One of the main problems with popular free tipsters is they can unintentionally cause odds to drop dramatically.

When thousands of bettors follow the same free tip, bookmakers adjust the odds, reducing the value of the bet for everyone.

This is something we discovered in our own review of the very popular tipster Hugh Taylor.

Whilst his tips made a profit of +9 points at advised prices during our trial, he finished -31 points down at the best prices available and -35 points down at Betfair SP.

So in reality, it would be very difficult to achieve a profit from following his tips. 

And even if you could, the bookies are very aware of services like Hugh Taylor and may well limit your account if they find you following his tips. 

Another example of the difficulty of odds availability with popular free tipsters is the golf tipster Ben Coley.

As we write this, one of his main tips this week, Matteo Manassero, was tipped at 66/1 – and happens to be leading the tournament at halfway!

But sadly when coming to place our own bet on him not long after Ben posted his tips, we could only achieve odds of 45/1.

That is not unusual for Mr Coley’s tips as he has a very large following as a successful free tipster at the Sporting Life. 

At the same time, this is not necessarily the case with all free tipsters. It is more a problem with the popular, well-known ones. 

If you are going to follow free tipsters, it is best to try and find some under-the-radar ones who are not well known to the betting public. 

For example, we have been monitoring a very promising golf tipster this year on Twitter/X called the Golf Gamblor, who has been producing some excellent results.  

With a much smaller following than the likes of Ben Coley or Hugh Taylor, the odds of his tips were more achievable. 

Sadly due to work pressures he has had to call time on his tipping for the time being, but hopefully he may come back at some stage.

Another very promising tipster we have been following is Michael Golf, who made over 2,000 points profit in 2023 and over 1,000 in 2024. 

🏆Rai wins at 50/1!!

Not sure what to even say about that one…

Most stressful watch of the year by far, massive relief after that birdie on 18! https://t.co/bDWZS9MmMA

— Michael (@Michaelgolf_) August 12, 2024

He had been offering his tips for free on Twitter/X but recently decided to go to a paid service on Patreon, but at a fee of only around £10 per month. 

In some ways that isn’t a bad thing though as it has meant odds do not crash quite as much with fewer people following the tips since it became a paid service. 

Another free tipster we are keeping an eye on is Keith’s Horse Racing Tips, which has made close to 1,000 points profit and has been posting free tips since March 2024.  

These kind of lesser-known free tipsters who do not experience quite the same price pressure can be much more appealing to follow than the big names, so it is worth keeping an eye out for them.

Although if they become successful the price pressure will almost certainly follow!

It is something of a catch-22 situation – the more successful they become, the bigger a following free tipsters get and the more the odds of their tips get smashed in.

So free tipster can often have a limited shelf-life, if they become successful. 

As mentioned above, the advantage of paid tipsters is they can limit their membership to counteract this problem. And they tend to have fewer followers to start with by dint of charging for their tips.  

 

Evaluating the True Value of Paid Services

Paid tipsters charge for their services, but it’s important to break down the costs and potential benefits to determine whether it’s worth it.

Breaking Down the Cost vs. Potential Returns

Paid services often come with a subscription fee, but the potential returns can justify the cost.

If a tipster consistently delivers positive ROI, the subscription fee may be a worthwhile investment.

For example, let’s take top horse racing service The Bookies Enemy. 

The tipster made a profit of over 150 points in 2023, which at £20 per point would be £3,000 profit. 

Subscription costs were £490 per year, so deducting that from £3,000 still leaves a net profit of +£2,510. 

It depends on how much your betting bank is and how much you can afford to stake of course, but in an example such as this it would have been well worth paying the subscription fee. 

Still, bettors need to weigh the cost of the service against their bankroll and expected returns in each case.

Additional Features and Resources Offered by Paid Services

Many paid services go beyond just tips. They often offer educational resources, detailed betting guides, access to members-only forums, and even real-time notifications.

These extras can provide additional value, making the service more appealing.

Incentive to Produce Consistent Profit 

The major goal of a paid tipster is to produce a profit for their members, obviously. If they do not, then they will lose members and therefore income. 

Anyone who has been a tipster for any length of time will tell you that membership numbers can fluctuate quite dramatically depending on results. 

If they are hitting lots of winners and producing significant profits, membership numbers often soar. 

Hit a losing run and have a losing month – let alone two or three – and membership numbers tend to plunge. 

So paid tipsters are highly incentivised to produce regular profits for their members. 

A free tipster doesn’t have quite the same concern however.

Many newspaper tipsters for example are paid a salary for producing daily tips, regardless of how those tips perform. 

Just take a look at the naps table for newspaper tipsters and see how many of them are in deficit overall!

Yes, it would be preferable for the tipster to make a profit, but it is not essential. The newspaper editor just wants some tips to fill column inches and go alongside the racecards in the paper. 

That is not to say that some free tipsters don’t try hard to produce a profit – and a number of them do make a profit.

It is more that a paid tipsters’ interests are much more aligned with you, the punter. They should be doing everything they can to make a profit and keep their membership happy. 

That doesn’t mean they will of course. As we have discovered here from reviewing hundreds of tipsters, most paid tipsters do not make money in the long run. 

Thankfully an elite few do manage to and those are the ones that are worth following.

 

Summing Up – Free Versus Paid Tipsters

In conclusion, the debate between free and paid sports tipsters is one that continues to divide the betting community. 

Free tipsters offer accessibility with no upfront cost, allowing bettors to explore a wide variety of sports and markets without paying a subscription fee. 

There are some really good free tipsters out there, like Ben Coley and Hugh Taylor.

However, free services often come with hidden drawbacks – in particular the pressure on odds when many followers jump on the same bet.

Paid tipsters, on the other hand benefit from smaller followings that can help preserve the odds of their tips.

While the upfront cost may deter some, the potential for a positive return on investment, along with added resources and support, can make paid tipsters worth it for serious bettors.

Looking at our lists of the best tipsters in sports including football, horse racing, tennis and golf for example, most of the best tipsters we have found tend to be paid. 

This is due in part to the fact that their odds are generally more available than the best free services, meaning in reality their results are more achievable. 

In our view then, it is worth paying the cost of signing up to a top paid tipster service if you are looking for a positive return in the long run.

It may not be initially as inviting to have to pay a fee versus getting tips for free, but in the long run with the right tipster, it can really pay off.